| 2020–21 | Liam John Vinal ’22 O-1970 |
| 2019–20 | Rey Armando Rodriguez ’21 O-1949 |
| 2019 | Terence Joseph Burke ’21 O-1936 |
| 2018–19 | Joshua David Nathanson ’20 O-1934 |
| 2018 | Noah Blake Goodman ’19 O-1911 (s) |
| 2017 | Maxwell Claus Wulff ’19 O-1909 (s) Thomas David Suesser ’18 O-1888 (f) |
| 2016 | Thomas David Suesser ’18 O-1888 |
| 2015 | Bryan Wesley Harriott ’17 O-1854 |
| 2014 | Daniel Anthony DeFlumeri ’15 O-1825 |
| 2013 | Matthew Stephen Clardy ’14 O-1779 |
| 2012 | Gabriel Jordan Mahan ’13 O-1787 (s) David Alan Cascione ’13 O-1773 (f) |
| 2011 | Steven Scott Robertson ’12 O-1746 |
| 2010 | Tyler John St. Pierre ’11 O-1732 |
| 2009 | Dax Jensen Acosta ’10 O-1716 |
| 2008 | Max Shapnik ’09 O-1712 |
| 2007 | Zachary Lee Halpern ’08 O-1687 |
| 2006 | David Brendan Cronheim ’07 O-1646 |
| 2005 | Michael C. Spinnicchia ’07 O-1660 |
| 2004 | Eric Miller Goldstein ’05 O-1623 |
| 2003 | Stephen Joseph DiNardo ’04 O-1609 |
| 2002 | Jonathan Douglass Emanuele ’03 O-1596 |
| 2001 | Benjamin Adam Steinberg ’02 O-1586 |
| 2000 | David Harold Salzman ’01 O-1568 |
| 1999 | Andrew D. Osborn ’00 O-1556 |
| 1998 | Myles David Blanchard ’99 O-1538 |
| 1997 | Jason Jiyon Cho ’98 O-1512 |
| 1996 | Daniel Philip Atlas ’98 O-1520 |
| 1995 | Gregory Campbell Knight ’96 O-1496 |
| 1994 | John Carey Barney, Jr. ’95 O-1476 |
| 1993 | Adam Michael Borah ’94 O-1477 |
| 1992 | Douglas Jay Piper ’93 O-1469 |
| 1991 | Daniel Brennan Cuffe ’92 O-1434 |
| 1990 | James Michael Dumas ’91 O-1416 |
| 1989 | Thomas Joseph Bruno ’90 O-1412 |
| 1988 | Andrew Craig Corsello ’89 O-1388 |
| 1987 | Peter Watridge ’88 O-1381 |
| 1986 | Leonard Marc Bardfelt ’87 O-1345 |
| 1985 | Christopher DiNapoli ’86 O-1333 |
| 1984 | Neil Joseph Tyrrell ’85 O-1324 |
| 1983 | John Gregory Tansey ’84 O-1302 |
| 1982 | Winston Douglas Jenks ’83 O-1285 |
| 1981 | Douglas Scott Skalka ’82 O-1273 |
| 1980 | Jonathan Bernard Turell ’81 O-1253 |
| 1979 | Richard Arthur Meigs, Jr. ’80 O-1230 |
| 1978 | Mark Vincent Hallock ’79 O-1215 |
| 1977 | Robert William Shaw II ’78 O-1208 |
| 1976 | Robert Michael Bocchino ’77 O-1184 |
| 1975 | John Russell Hayner ’76 O-1175 |
| 1974 | Andrew Arthur Reilly ’75, O-1163 |
| 1973 | James Wenz McClymonds, Jr. ’74 O-1148 |
| 1972 | Kenneth Carl Huber ’73 O-1131 |
| 1971 | Bruce Charles MacKenzie ’72 O-1115 |
| 1970 | Robert Gilbert Woodworth ’71 O-1100 |
| 1969 | John Ray Lombardi ’70 O-1079 |
| 1968 | Joseph Bernard Kelley ’69 O-1040 (s) Charles Judson Young ’69 O-1053 (f) |
| 1967 | Randolph Earnest Parker ’68 O-1023 |
| 1966 | Ralph Vincent Wilhelm, Jr. ’67 O-995 |
| 1965 | Jacques Martin Wood ’66 O-998 |
| 1964 | Alan Roy Fridkin ’65 O-965 |
| 1963 | Robert Lee Bamberger ’64 O-945 |
| 1962 f | Hamlin Miller “Sandy” Gilbert ’62 O-933 |
| 1962 s | William Graf Imig ’63 O-938 |
| 1961 | John Ernest Kempster ’62 O-926 |
| 1960 | Richard Douglas Nelson ’61 O-911 (s) David Murray Goelzer ’62 O-897 (f) |
| 1959 | Helge Alan Hoglund ’60 O-852 (s) Joseph Anthony Persivale ’61 O-889 (f) |
| 1958 | Carl Joseph Igelbrink ’59 O-853 |
| 1957 | Wendell Lee Fingar ’58 O-849 (s) Albert Ellison Kurdle ’58 O-831 (f) |
| 1956 | James Gardner Plunkett ’58 O-802 |
| 1955 | Homer Folks Orton ’56 O-801 |
| 1954 | Alfred Theodore Blomquist, Jr. ’55 O-772 |
| 1953 | Thomas Ernst Bechert ’54 O-737 |
| 1952 | Luther Harold Haibt ’54 O-738 |
| 1951 | Robert Easton Vanderbeck ’52 O-713 |
| 1950 | Theodore Frank Decker ’50 O-675 |
| 1949 | Soeren Steinbock Nielsen ’47 O-569 |
| 1948 | Richard Lee Quasey ’48 O-642 |
| 1948 | Wilbur Robbins Dameron ’49 |
| 1947 | Edward Taylor Moore ’48 O-625 |
| 1946 | Frederick Mahler ’48 (NE-) |
| 1946 | Jacob David Fry ’45 O-570 |
| 1945 | Raymond Howard Schumacher ’48 O-602 |
| 1944 | William Charles Miller ’47 O-595 |
| 1944 | Richard Emil Turner ’46 |
| 1943 | James H. Barrett ’43 |
| 1942 | Warren Hunter Fisher ’43 O-380 |
| 1941 | Donald Lawson Bundy ’42 O-369 |
| 1940 | Henry William Lengyel ’41 O-452 |
| 1939 | James William Robinson ’40 O-338 |
| 1938 | Carl Thompson Hewitt Jr. ’39 O-341 |
| 1937 | Clement Frederick Harris ’38 O-326 |
| 1936 | Royal David Thomas Jr. ’37 O-318 |
| 1935 | Charles Edward Robinson Jr. ’36 O-300 |
| 1934 | Harry Franklin Fowler ’35 O-298 |
| 1933 | William Anderson Rider ’34 O-281 |
| 1932 | Francis Raymond Keating Jr. ’33 O-266 |
| 1931 | Wilfrid Ewart Rhodes ’30 O-231 |
| 1930 | Leroy Hamilton Wardner ’31, O-244 |
| 1929 | Robert James Wallace ’30 O-229 |
| 1928 | John Charles Little, Jr. ’28 O-206 (s) William Bissell McLean ’29 O-200 (f) |
| 1927 | Irving Theodore Runey ’28 O-201 |
| 1926 | Sherman Richmond Knapp, Sr. ’27 O-186 |
| 1925 | Harold Joseph Shackelton ’26 O-168 |
| 1924 | John Noll, Jr. ’25 O-149 |
| 1923 | Robert Dwight Hopkins, Jr. ’24 O-146 |
| 1922 | Lawrence Mitchell Orton ’21 O-102 |
| 1921 | William Forrester Stotz ’20 O-88 |
| 1920 | Searles Gregory Shultz ’20 O-94 |
| 1919 | Horace John McNeil ’19 O-75 |
| 1918 | Dean Edward Lounsbery ’19 O-78 |
| 1917 f | Wesley Yeomans Huntley ’18 |
| 1917 s | George Clinton Sweet ’18 O-67 |
| 1916 | Geoffrey Edward Maclay ’17 O-60 |
| 1915 | George Raymond Allen ’15 O-28 |
| 1914 | Earl Milton Clay ’15 O-13 |
| 1913 | Benjamin LeCompte Smith ’13 O-8 |
Notes
The High Alpha, for most of the chapter's history, served for the spring then fall semesters. The first, Benjamin Smith, was originally elected as the fifth “Herr Vorsitzender” of the Iswza Society, and continued in the presidency after the installation of Omicron Zeta in October 1913. Starting in 2018, the High Alpha transitioned to an academic year cycle, serving for the fall then spring, to be held in perpetuity by a junior.
This list was compiled from a number of sources. The primary and preferred record is chapter election reports, followed by listings in the Omicron Oracle and Omicron Alumni News, composite photographs, and mentions in the Cross & Crescent or other sources from outside the chapter. Anyone who can provide clarifications or corrections to this list is urged to contact the Heritage Committee.